Oil palm crushed

When the local stock index is making new record highs but your portfolio of local stocks is not (last high watermark was woefully back in Feb 2012), you can be sure there must be a few lagging stocks in there.


Norway drops Asian palm oil firms in show of green credentials

* Fund sells out of 23 Asian firms to slow deforestation

* Environmentalists welcome shift, urge more action

By Joachim Dagenborg and Alister Doyle

OSLO, March 8 (Reuters) – Norway’s $710 billion sovereign wealth fund has pulled out of 23 Asian palm oil companies after accusing them of causing deforestation, winning praise from environmentalists.

It said it sold stakes in the firms after a review of companies that have cleared forests for palm oil plantations in Malaysia and Indonesia. Palm oil is used in many foods and consumer goods such as soaps, lipstick and peanut butter.

The fund is one of the world’s biggest investors, underpinned by Norway’s oil and gas assets. Last year it expanded its investment guidelines to include deforestation as a threat to future growth.

Stakes in firms including Wilmar, KL Kepong and Golden Agri-Resources Ltd were sold during 2012, according to the fund’s annual report released on Friday.

Of these, the biggest holding had been in Singapore-listed Wilmar, worth 382 million crowns ($67.29 million).

“In the first quarter of 2012 we sold our stakes in 23 companies that by our reckoning produced palm oil unsustainably,” the fund said, without naming any firms.

Norway has given more than any other developed nation to help slow deforestation, partly as a way to avert climate change. Indonesia is home to the world’s third-largest expanse of tropical forests and is the top prodicer of palm oil. Malaysia is the world’s second largest producer.

The companies deny that they are a threat to forests.

Golden Agri’s website, for instance, says: “we aim to be the leader in sustainable palm oil production.” Wilmar and KL Kepong similarly say that they support best practices and standards to protect the environment.


The Rainforest Foundation environmental group has long accused Norway of double standards by investing billions of dollars in palm oil or soya farmers while also giving cash to nations from Brazil to Indonesia to slow deforestation.

“We are very happy with this development in the palm oil sector,” said Nils Hermann Ranum, of Norway’s branch of the Foundation.

Still, he said that Norway should do more to pull out of other sectors that cause deforestation, such as logging companies, oil and gas firms, soya and meat producers.

By the Foundation’s estimates, Norway had investments totalling $13.2 billion in companies damaging rainforests at the end of 2012, against $14.4 billion a year earlier. “They need a more coherent policy,” he said.

Norway has programmes to slow deforestation worth $1 billion each for Brazil and Indonesia, as well as smaller projects in nations from Guyana to Tanzania.

Many companies, including Anglo-Dutch consumer group Unilever Plc and Swiss food group Nestle, have cracked down on palm oil suppliers in recent years because of worries about deforestation.

Deforestation accounts for up to about a fifth of greenhouse gases from human sources. Forests soak up carbon dioxide as they grow and release it when they burn or rot.

Yngve Slyngstad, head of Norway’s fund, told Reuters that Oslo was trying to invest more in palm oil producers whose policies did not damage forests that are home to endangered animals such as orang-utans and absorb greenhouse gases.

“We have sold many of the small companies and concentrated investment in larger companies who often have a better practice,” he said.

Among palm oil firms, the fund more than quadrupled its holdings in Malaysia’s Sime Darby to a value of 688.8 million crowns at the end of 2012 from 150.7 million crowns a year earlier.

Palm oil stocks pressed and crushed by the double whammy of declining CPO prices as well as a large shareholder suddenly possessed by a righteous sense of Sustainability.

Oh well, it could had been worse. I could be holding oil seeds and olam and faced with short-selling activists hell-bent on muddying the waters. Consoling myself now with clipping the coupons/cashing in the dividend checks of the retail reits which somehow and fortuitously ended up in the portfolio. In this current near-ZIRP environment here there and everywhere, high single-digit yields seem so princely…

But one man’s misery may be another man’s opportunity. I wonder if a friend involved in carbon sequestration and other CDM projects may be seeing more opportunities, despite the collapse in CER prices (courtesy of Obama and his successful burying of the Kyoto Protocol at Copenhagen in 2009) a little while back. This is one aspect of the plantation industry I have always been interested in, probably for familial and ancestry reasons.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s